Label: Film Score Monthly
Catalogue No: FSM BOX 04
Release Date: 12-Jan-2010
Total Duration:
Box set with 15 CDs. Limited edition of 2000 copies
In the printed booklet notes to this handsomely presented box set, producer Lukas Kendall reveals that when FSM first began a CD contractual arrangement with Warner Bros/Turner Entertainment Co., who own the classic M-G-M film library, it was Rózsa who was foremost in his mind. Hardly surprising, of course, because when Rózsa was under contract to M-G-M he was at the height of his creative powers, when his romanticism came to the fore, especially for historical dramas, and he scored one masterwork after another. Kendall goes on to say that having cherry-picked some of Rózsa’s greatest scores for single disc release, it was appropriate to assess how to make the remaining material available – the result of which is this opulent box set of 15 discs, containing over 14 hours of music, which sweeps up just about every Rózsa note remaining on the studio floor. There were, no doubt, practical business reasons to combine all the remaining material in a special collector’s item, because scores from less well-known films such as TIP ON A DEAD JOCKEY and CREST OF THE WAVE would perhaps have been a hard sell as individual CD releases – better therefore to produce a limited edition box set combining every remaining unreleased score which, as a unique item, would be eagerly welcomed by Rózsa’s legion of world-wide admirers.
It is a source of unending regret that the original music tracks for Rózsa’s QUO VADIS have not surfaced from the studio vaults. To make amends, FSM have made available a reconstruction which offers the most substantial amount of material we are ever likely to have of the original music albeit with the inclusion of some sound effects. The result is most worthwhile with music such as that for the first meeting between Marcus and Lygia being heard for the first time without intrusive dialogue. As well as one complete disc of this reconstruction, a second disc of QUO VADIS is provided which includes the original M-G-M soundtrack album and numerous other tracks of original pre-recordings, marches, fanfares etc. The amount of music from the film is far more than any of us could ever have hoped for and FSM have clearly gone to extraordinary lengths to make the material available in the best possible sound quality, bearing in mind the apparent poor state of some of the original elements.
Madame Bovary is an important score in Rózsa’s oeuvre being the first of his M-G-M historical pictures, which immediately demonstrated his flair for scoring that type of film, helped immensely by Rózsa’s enthusiastic research into the music of the past, to ensure that his music was as faithful as possible to the period in question. The music is familiar from the recording made by Elmer Bernstein for his Film Music Collection (also available as a CD box set from FSM) but it’s good to have the score in such a complete version. As with so many of the early Rózsa scores not all the music tracks have survived and so, as with QUO VADIS, FSM have utilised some combined music/effects cues. I didn’t find the inclusion of effects terribly distracting and it’s surely far better to include them, rather than have an incomplete score of such a major work.
CREST OF THE WAVE was a rather static film which bore all the hallmarks that it was based on a stage play. Unfortunately, as a film, the mixture of dangerous military weapons testing and weak British humour amongst the ranks, just didn’t seem to jell. Rózsa’s sparse score is similarly afflicted in being somewhat schizophrenic; alternating between the serious and the comic – and if it was one thing that Rózsa was not adept at (as he himself admitted) it was “comic” music; which unfortunately comes across here as clichéd and overstated. However, the dramatically scored music is excellent and fortunately all of the music has been preserved.
Anyone watching ALL THE BROTHERS WERE VALIANT could be forgiven for wondering how a composer with Rózsa’s reputation could have written such clichéd tropical island music. Well, of course, Rózsa did no such thing. The CD for this score contains Rózsa’s complete score together with a separate disc section containing music composed by John Green and Conrad Salinger for the island scenes; amongst others. This is a stirring robustly-themed Rózsa score of great variety. It’s a score which has been under-rated but Rozsaphiles but, as presented here in expansive stereo, will hopefully gain further recognition and appreciation.
The completeness of this collection is remarkable – not just the completeness of each score in the set but FSM have gone the extra mile in ensuring that music which was not provided for reasons of space on discs originally released on the Rhino label, is included as well, such as extra music from KING OF KINGS – of which I particularly like the addition of choir and/or organ on some of the alternative cues. I’m not sure what can charitably be said about the Italian choral version of “The Prayer of Our Lord” but it’s fascinating to hear, nonetheless!
One of the most attractive Rózsa “themed” LPs was “Great Movie Themes Composed by Miklos Rózsa”. These concert-style arrangements of Rózsa’s most popular themes are at last available on this set, sounding better than ever before. The original LP soundtracks of EL CID, KING OF KINGS and THE V.I.P.s are also here in newly remastered sound. Most welcome is the complete Muir Mathieson conducted KNIGHTS OF THE ROUND TABLE and the original tracks for THE POWER, which until recently, were thought to have deteriorated too far to be saved.
Obviously it’s unfortunate that so much music from some of Rózsa’s early M-G-M films no longer survives. I would have liked, for example, to have heard more of THE MINIVER STORY which Rózsa adapted from Herbert Stothart’s themes. The excerpts are enjoyable although it’s difficult to know exactly where Stothart ends and Rózsa begins. It’s also a shame that so little of EAST SIDE, WEST SIDE survives. I wonder in this case why the Main and End Titles could not have been taken from the film soundtrack. Fortunately THE LIGHT TOUCH has survived in full – an extremely melodic, enjoyable score, with Rózsa in high-spirited fun mode.
I’ve barely scratched the surface of the content of this massive box set and haven’t even mentioned YOUNG BESS, THE STORY OF THREE LOVES and TIP ON A DEAD JOCKEY or the atypical Rózsa scores, SOMETHING OF VALUE and CRISIS The degree of completeness which I mentioned before, even extends to the inclusion of cues of Rózsa’s music adapted for use in films scored by other composers.
The set is complemented with detailed notes which are available on the FSM website. I cannot praise these extensive notes enough and clearly Lukas Kendall, Alexander Kaplan and Rozsa experts, John Fitzpatrick, Frank DeWald and George Komar have invested considerable time and effort in making them as comprehensive as possible. Apart from notes on the individual scores, I particularly like the opening “Rózsa M-G-M Chronology” which succinctly places every score in context. Whilst it would have been wonderful to have had these notes contained within a booklet together with the box set, it’s understandable that such a booklet would have had to be massive, and correspondingly expensive. In fact, printing the notes provides one with a book of over 150 A4 pages!
This is very much a labour of love by FSM for Miklós Rózsa’s worldwide followers and deserves the highest accolade for being the finest and most ambitious Rózsa soundtrack collection ever issued.
© 2016 / 2024 CINESCORES CENTER
Visit the representative website of Hugo Friedhofer - GO TO SITE
WE WOULD LIKE TO SPECIAL THANKS FOR THE PHOTOGRAPHIC PRINTS
DIMITRI TIOMKIN OFFICIAL WEBSITE - MIKLOS ROZSA OFFICIAL WEBSITE
FRANZ WAXMAN OFFICIAL WEBSITE - BERNARD HERRMANN OFFICIAL
LUC VAN DE VEN - SOUNDTRACK!
UNIVERSAL PICTURES - FOX STUDIO - MGM PRODUCTIONS
WARNER
BROS - PHOTOS GENERAL ALL RIGHTS RESERVED >
DISCLAMER
NEWS