Label: Screen Archives Entertainment
Catalogue No: FILMCD 177
Release Date: 2002
Total Duration: 60:36
UPN: 0738572108021
The Ealing comedies, with their controlled anarchy, have long been a treasured part of Britain's cinematic heritage - so much so that the term “Ealing comedy” has almost become generic, synonymous in peoples minds with other British comedies of the period, not actually made by the studio. This CD brings together themes and suites from the best loved and best remembered comedies (and some of their fine dramas), composed by an impressive array of names who were among the most important of their generation, both in the film world and the concert hall.
One of the first things one listens out for in a release such as this, is the degree of success with which the music on offer makes the transition from its filmic origins to the more abstract format of a commercial recording. These days, its fair to say, producers and composers have any eye out for the inevitable soundtrack album, with the result that complete and coherent sequences and suites are composed and recorded, even when they may not be fully required for use in the films themselves. But in the heyday of Ealing and other studios, composers wrote entirely to order, often creating musical segments lasting just a few seconds (so- called 'Mickey-Mousing'), in order to capture the mood of specific events as the screenplays unfolded. This would mean that the title and end sequences, along with the odd extended action sequence, for example, afforded composers their only opportunities to write complete and inherently logical music statements. As it turns out, this CD proves to be an entertaining, self sufficient, compilation of scores, discerningly chosen and assembled.
The background to this release deserve a mention, for it took Silva Screen's mastermind, David Wishart, just over three years to bring this, his long- cherished brainchild, to fruition, given the attendant problems: the inevitable, largely futile search for extant music material (often missing or long since destroyed); the need for costly and time-consuming reconstruction of the remaining selections desired (undertaken here by the stalwart CO- producer Phillip Lane); the routine problems of engaging orchestra and conductor, and scheduling the sessions. So what of the final outcome.
Well, the engagement of the Royal Ballet Sinfonia produces far more assured and polished results than were achieved in some of Silva Screen's earlier releases, in which the playing of the Westminster Philharmonic (a non- professional body) made up in enthusiastic commitment what it may have lacked in technical finesse. Once again, the seasoned hand of conductor Kenneth Alwyn is at the helm and his association with Silva Screen has proved highly fruitful. Sound - engineered once again by Mike Ross-Trevor - is characteristically clean and spacious and the accompanying sixteen-page booklet with the, by now, familiarly literate and informative notes by David Wishart, is nicely presented. And so to the music itself.
The CD kicks off with Benjamin Frankel's ingenious theme for THE MAN IN THE WHITE SUIT, depicting the mechanical looms of the northern textile factory where the story takes place. Like the screenplay itself, Frankel's music here has a dark and unsettling side to it. This is one of the many sequences that Phillip Lane had to reconstruct and, declaring my own specialist knowledge of Frankel's music, I noticed a number of details which vary from the composer's original, although the essential spirit of the music is preserved.
In the case of the French composer Georges Auric - three of those scores are featured here. Phillip Lane was able to obtain some of the original sketches from the composer's widow, thus enabling faithful reconstruction of PASSPORT TO PIMLICO, THE TITFIELD THUNDERBOLT, and THE LAVENDER HILL MOB to be made. As a Frenchman, Auric might appear to have been odd-man-out in the quintessentially British world of Ealing comedies but the first and last of the aforementioned titles have distinctly French plot connections. Auric, who also composed the score for the French classic LA BELLE ET LA BÊTE and the celebrated British horror film DEAD OF NIGHT, was a member of 'Les Six' - a group of French composers, including Poulenc and Milhaud, who were associated during the twenties and noted for their spirited musical humour.
By way of contrast, Alan Rawsthorne (Benjamin Frankel's near exact contemporary) is featured here is three scores he composed for Ealing dramas - THE CRUEL SEA, THE CAPTIVE HEART, and SARABAND FOR DEAD LOVERS, providing a welcome change of mood. The influence of Prokofiev and Shostakovich seems to surface here and one looks forward to the projected release of an all-Rawsthorne album in the near future. Until then, this fine selection should create an appetite.
Ernest Irving who, as Ealing's music director, was responsible for recruiting the talents of so many notable British composers to the studio was himself a capable composer, as illustrated here by his score for WHISKY GALORE.
The underrated Gerard Schumann who produced a number of interesting film scores, alongside his concert works, specially arranged his overture to MAN IN THE SKY for this release, to dramatic effect. Similarly Tristram Cary created a coherent three-movement suite from his score for THE LADYKILLERS, wittily juxtaposing memorable themes from string quartets by Haydn and Boccherini (the much loved Minuet from Op. 13, No.5), amid more sinister music from this blackest of Ealing comedies. The fact that the quintet of crooks poses as a string 'quartet' adds considerably to the fun. One should not overlook Phillip Lane's skilful arrangement of music by Mozart, taken from the famous KIND HEARTS AND CORONETS.
The final offering here is John Ireland's 'Stampede for Water' from his only film score THE OVERLANDERS. This music, in an arrangement by the composer Geoffrey Bush, forms the second of Ireland's Two Symphonic Studies' and was not, in fact, incorporated into the familiar concert suite of the score.
Overall, this is a fine release which film fans in general, and Ealing buffs in particular, will surely want to add to their collections. No doubt material reconstructed by repeated auditioning iS of soundtracks is not as ideal as the original music on which it is based - as iS the case with some of these selections - but, without it, and the sterling efforts of all concerned, this project could not have become a reality.
Originally published in Music from the Movies Issue 17, 1997
© 2016 / 2024 CINESCORES CENTER
Visit the representative website of Hugo Friedhofer - GO TO SITE
WE WOULD LIKE TO SPECIAL THANKS FOR THE PHOTOGRAPHIC PRINTS
DIMITRI TIOMKIN OFFICIAL WEBSITE - MIKLOS ROZSA OFFICIAL WEBSITE
FRANZ WAXMAN OFFICIAL WEBSITE - BERNARD HERRMANN OFFICIAL
LUC VAN DE VEN - SOUNDTRACK!
UNIVERSAL PICTURES - FOX STUDIO - MGM PRODUCTIONS
WARNER
BROS - PHOTOS GENERAL ALL RIGHTS RESERVED >
DISCLAMER
NEWS