Blog Post

1984

Kirk Henderson

Publisher: Music from the Movies


Publication: Issue 20 - Summer 1998, pp 42-44


Copyright © Music from the Movies Ltd 1998. All rights reserved.

It is really hard to understand why Malcolm Arnold's score to 1984 has become an orphan because even if it had nothing else going for it besides one of the composer's finest marches, that alone is reason enough for a re-recording. Beyond that, Arnold's effectively quirky score is gripping and imaginative. Perhaps the Orwell estate's dissatisfaction with the film and their subsequent unwillingness to see it re-released contributed to the unfamiliarity of the score. The US version is only available in illegal washed-out, splicy video copies, where not only is the picture bad, but the soundtrack is almost incomprehensible.


Puzzling - Aside from all this, the score was written by one of Britain's most visible and popular of composers. That at least a suite from the film has never made it to disc in any form is puzzling. Much of Arnold's film work is available in some form or another, although it is true that many of the original LPs are out of print. Even if that was not the case, when his film work is referred to in the liner notes of his various symphonic works as well as his re-recorded film scores, hardly ever is 1984 included. Yet 1984 is classic Arnold in the very best sense, and a closer listen is well rewarded.

Orwell’s 1949 book, whose independent-thinking main character, Winston Smith, is ultimately crushed by an oppressive political system inspired by an all-seeing imaginary figure called 'Big Brother', was initially produced for British television in the mid-fifties. It was first made into a motion picture in 1956, a black and white production directed by Michael Anderson, with a miscast Edmond O'Brien as a heavyish Winston Smith and Jan Sterling as Julia, the woman Winston clandestinely falls for. The film had a reasonable budget and incorporated large sets, matte paintings and miniatures to create the illusion of a sprawling futuristic city where oppression was all-encompassing. Arnold's sparse score was written a year prior to his Academy Award-winning music for David Lean's THE BRIDGE ON THE RIVER KWAI.

Unlike many American composers whose concert career was damaged by writing film scores, Malcolm Arnold managed to maintain respect in both fields throughout Europe. His many symphonies and concert works continue to be played around the world, and many of these works remain available on disc. His film work is now becoming more accessible, with suites from WHISTLE DOWN THE WIND and HOBSON'S CHOICE among others, newly recorded. 1984, however, seems to have been abandoned.


Impressive march - If one isolates the sections of 1984 with Arnold's music from the rest of the film, the result is a strange listening experience, for the score is primarily made up of variations on an impressive march, both bold and martial in nature, with an unnerving forward motion. Along with this march there is a series of what we now refer to generically as 'muzak' pieces. Other than that there is a dreamy love theme accompanying Winston and Julia's various rendezvous and lastly, a variety of musical stings and severe fanfares which recur during moments of terror or torture. With the stings and fanfares removed, what remains is hardly a stark listening experience, yet the cumulative effect is one of insidious resignation, an almost giving-in to the oppression. The muzak pieces, unobtrusive music hall background ditties to keep the populace complacent just spin along without vigour or variance, just like elevator muzak. When an announcement comes over a tele-screen accompanied by a forceful fanfare, the contrast is welcome. Finally, some music with guts; it makes us want to like Big Brother.

In the film these muzak pieces are used as source music, relegated to the spaces between broadcasts of party propaganda, playing mildly during scenes in Winston's home quarters or at the cafeteria where the ubiquitous tele-screens can be seen calmly observing humanity. The volume and the flatness of the recording and performance keep us barely aware of them. Although there are a number of different melodies, the cumulative effect is a single, nondescript piece of harmonic mediocrity that drones us into indifference. Yet this is controlled writing, very effective in its ability to lull us into a false sense of security.


The contrast is striking, however, when composer Arnold actually presents us with true underscore, as he does in the scene when Winston, still thinking Julia is a spy for the 'thought police', sees her come into the antique shop where he has just purchased a paperweight. Though we clearly see Winston's utter terror at thinking he is being followed, he keeps his emotions in check until he leaves the shop and runs away in panic. Arnold holds back as well, waiting for the moment when Winston is outside to let the orchestra loose in a short flight of musical fear The strings wind up in a repetitive statement of alarm while directionless brass search for a way out. This continues as Winston runs through the dark streets and we come to realize we are hearing a variation on the main theme march which has worked its way through the chaos. How fitting that the cue ends when Winston is stopped by the police.


Forward drive - This indefatigable march is pure Malcolm Arnold. He was never afraid of intensity, but his music always seemed to be tempered by reeds or flute, so as not to alienate the listener completely. Similarities to this approach can be heard during his main title music for Lean's RIVER KWAI which shows a crew of prisoners-of-war cutting through a harsh jungle to make way for a railroad. Although the Kwai piece is not a march, it has the same determined forward drive displayed in the pounding percussion and heavy brass. This sequence's only respite is solo flute which accompanies a gliding bird through a clear sky.

In the case of 1984s opening titles, Arnold begins with an uplifting fanfare on strings and woodwinds. By the time the title appears the fanfare has taken a sharp dive into Arnold's stringent march which is written for brass and punctuated by crashing cymbals. It’s as if we were hearing a march meant for a thousand unstoppable tanks. At the credits' finish we see an aerial view of Oceania and the score takes a cautious tone in its use of vibrato strings joined by flute, which continue to play the 1984 march in an unnerving yet restrained and sober form. Over this we see the quote: “This is the story of the future. Not the future of spaceships and men from other planets, but the immediate future.” The tone has been set for what we are about to see.

Unfortunately, what we see is not as effective as it could have been. Director Michael Anderson, who in 1976 gave us the cheesily fake LOGAN'S RUN, at least did better here with Orwell's material, but he was working with a fairly mundane screenplay by William P. Templeton and Ralph Bettinson. And although Jan Sterling was better as the wife of a ghost in television’s Topper, she didn't seem so out of place as Edmond O'Brien who might have been effectively paranoid in D.O.A. (1950), but in 1984 just plain overacts. His stocky build didn't lend itself to the emaciated character in Orwell's novel either.

At least we have Arnold's score, which is one of the few soundly dynamic elements in the entire film. One might take issue with the overtly romantic love theme for Winston and Julia which is perhaps a bit dated by today’s standards, but it’s dear that without a little sweetness the film would have been unbearable to sit through. (The people who did the remake also realized this and sought to alleviate oppression via music).

Once Winston is brought to the Ministry of Love to be interrogated we never hear the love theme again. Instead we sit through Winston's brainwashing and torture - overseen by inner party member O'Conner (a very effective Michael Redgrave) - without music but for some shrill brass fanfares which accompany a few dissolves in time. The finest musical cue in the whole film follows Winston's release from the Ministry of Love. As he steps through the town square and sees Julia sitting by herself, Arnold has a subdued rendition of the 1984 march accompany him. There is a tremolo in the strings as they glide through the familiar theme and in spite of the repressed tone, the forward motion is still there, only temporarily holding back, as if watching and waiting, making sure Winston has in fact been 'cleansed'. After he walks away from Julia he joins a crowd in a cry of “Long Live Big Brother,” and Arnold's march returns in its greatest severity.


Ahead of its time - It should be mentioned that one problem which plagued this production since the start was its multiple endings, no doubt a thorn in the side of the Orwell estate. A British version has Winston killed as a result of his sacrificial attempt to stir the crowd, but this version, imposed by the producers who feared the original ending too bleak, never made it to the US. The ending discussed here is the American one, which more closely conforms to the ending of the book. And Malcolm Arnold's music for this ending is as effective as anything he has ever written. His transformation of the main theme from hesitant watchdog to crashing march is a stunning piece of work, rarely equalled. All in all, Arnold's 1984 is an amazingly varied score, one of his most inventive. Yet in spite of this variety, Arnold's use of 'muzak' as a mind-control device is one of the more effective elements of the score, perhaps even a bit ahead of its time. Muzak certainly existed in 1956 but it wasn't known by that name and didn't become pervasive until the sixties, so Arnold's use of it as a mind-numbing force in 1956 is pretty astounding indeed. Oddly, director Michael Radford's remake, which was produced and released in the year 1984, is fully scored but uses no muzak whatsoever.

That Malcolm Arnold's impressive march for 1984 has never made it to disc in any form - let alone any other part of this interesting score - is a shameless oversight, to say the least. To put it more appropriately, it's nothing less than a 'thought crime'.

by Pascal Dupont 10 May, 2024
Charles Allan Gerhardt English version adapted by Doug Raynes - FRENCH VERSION AND COLLECTION had a reputation as a great conductor, record producer and musical arranger. His major work at RCA on the Classic Film Scores series earned him recognition from film music devotees of Hollywood’s Golden Age, as well as other renowned conductors of his day. Born on February 6, 1927 in Detroit, Michigan, Charles Gerhardt developed a passion for music and percussion instruments from an early age. At the age of five, he took piano lessons, and by the age of nine, had established a solid reputation as an orchestrator and composer. He spent his early school years in Little Rock, Arkansas, then after 10 years, having completed his schooling, moved with his family to Illinois for his military duties, he served in the U.S. Navy during World War II as a chaplain's aide in the Aleutian Islands, then became an active member of the Veterans of Foreign Wars. He went on to study at the University of Illinois, at the College of William and Mary, and later at the University of Southern California. Throughout his time at school Gerhardt was attracted not only to music, but also to the sciences. Passionate about the art of recording, he joined Westminster Records for five years, until the company ceased operations, and then joined Bell Sound. One day, he received a phone call from George Marek to meet with the heads of Reader's Digest, to discuss producing recordings for their mail-order record business; a contact that was to secure his musical future and a rich career spanning more than 30 years. Gerhardt's first job for Reader's Digest was to produce a record; “A Festival of Light Classical Music”; a 12 LP box set that he produced in full. One of Gerhardt's finest projects was the production of another 12 LP box set, “Les Trésores de la Grande Musique (Treasury of Great Music)”, featuring the Royal Philharmonic Orchestra conducted by some of the leading figures of the day: Charles Munch to Bizet and Tchaikovsky, Rudolf Kempe to Strauss and Respighi, Josef Krips to Mozart and Haydn, Antal Dorati to Strauss and Berlioz, Brahms 4th Symphony by Fritz Reiner and Sibelius’ 2nd Symphony by Sir John Barbirolli. In the 1950s he conducted works by Vladimir Horowitz, Wanda Landowska, Kirsten Flagstad and William Kapeli. In the early 1960s, Gerhardt lived in England, where he made most of his recordings, but kept a foothold in the United States, mainly in New York. Often, when he went to the United States after a period of recording sessions, he would stop off in Baltimore and spend some time listening to cassettes of his new recordings. Gerhardt loved percussion instruments, especially tam-tams. One of his favorite recordings was the Columbia mono disc of Scriabin's Poem of Ecstasy, with Dimitri Mitropoulos and the New York Philharmonic. He had great admiration and respect for the many conductors he worked with, starting with Arturo Toscanini, with whom he worked for several years before the Maestro's death. It was Toscanini who suggested that Gerhardt become a conductor, which he did! His career as an orchestra director began when he had to replace a conductor who failed to show up for rehearsals. It was a position he would later occupy for various recording sessions and occasional concerts. His classical recordings include works by Richard Strauss, Tchaikovsky, Wagner, Ravel, Debussy, Walton and Howard Hanson. Hired by RCA Records, he transferred 78 rpm recordings of Enrico Caruso and other artists to 33 rpm. He took part in recordings by soprano singer Kirsten Flagstad and pianist Vladimir Horowitz. He worked with renowned conductors such as Fritz Reiner, Leopold Stokowski and Charles Munch, from whom he learned the tricks of the trade. Still at RCA, he assisted Arturo Toscanini, with whom he perfected his conducting skills. Then, in 1960, he produced recordings for RCA and Reader’s Digest in London, and joined forces with sound engineer Kenneth Wilkinson of Decca Records (RCA's European subsidiary), The two men got on very well and shared a passion for recording and sound quality, making an incredible number of recordings over a 30-year period. Also in 1960, RCA and Reader's Digest entrusted him with the production of a 12-disc LP box set entitled “ Lumière du Classique (A Festival of Light Classical Music) ”, sold exclusively by mail order. With a budget of $250,000, Gerhardt assumed total control of the project: repertoire, choice of orchestras and production. He recorded in London, Vienna and Paris, and hired such top names as Sir Adrian Boult, Massimo Freccia, Sir Alexander Gibson and René Leibowitz. The success of this project, in terms of both musical quality and sound, earned him recognition from his employers. Other projects of similar scope followed… A boxed set of Beethoven's symphonic works with René Leibowitz and The Royal Philharmonic Orchestra. A boxed set of Rachmaninoff's works for piano and orchestra with Earl Wild, Jascha Horenstein and the Royal Philharmonic Orchestra, the above mentioned 12 LP disc set “Trésor de la Grande Musique (Treasury of Great Music)” with the Royal Philharmonic conducted by some of the greatest directors of the time: Fritz Reiner, Charles Munch, Rudolf Kempe, Sir John Barbirolli, Sir Malcolm Sargent, Antal Dorati and Jascha Horenstein, with whom Gerhardt had sympathized. In January 1964 in London, Gerhardt joined forces with Sidney Sax, instrumentalist and conductor, to form a freelance orchestra. This successful group went on to join the National Philharmonic Orchestra of London, an impressive line-up that would later become Jerry Goldsmith's orchestra of choice. With Peter Munves, head of RCA's classical division, he conceived the idea of recording an album devoted exclusively to the film music of Erich Wolfgang Korngold, one of his favorite composers. Enthusiastic about the project, Munves gave Gerhardt carte blanche, and was offered a helping hand by George Korngold, producer and son of the famous Viennese composer, who owned all the copies of his father's scores. The Adventure Began : The Sea Hawk: Classic Film Scores of Erich Wolfgang Korngold. For this first disc, Gerhardt selected 10 scores by Korngold, which he recorded in the Kingsway Hall Studio in London, renowned for its excellent acoustics. The disc thus benefits from optimal recording conditions, favoring at the same time the performances of the National Philharmonic (and its leader, Sidney Sax), a formidable orchestra made up of London's finest musicians and freelance soloists. Each album was recorded in the same studio, with Kenneth Wilkinson as sound engineer and George Korngold as consultant/producer. As soon as it was released, the album's success received strong acclaim in classical music circles and received a feature in Billboard No. 37, a first in this category in December 1972. It took no less than a year to sell the first 10,000 copies in all the specialist record suppliers and the album went on to sell over 38,000 copies, making it the fifth best-selling album in the “classical” category in 1973. On the strength of this success, Peter Munves and RCA entrusted Charles Gerhardt with the production of further discs devoted to other world-renowned composers of Hollywood music. The program includes several albums dedicated to Max Steiner and Erich Wolfgang Korngold plus one each to Miklos Rozsa, Franz Waxman, Dimitri Tiomkin and Bernard Herrmann, followed by 3 volumes associated with specific film stars such as Bette Davis, Errol Flynn and Humphrey Bogart. Then, a disc devoted to Alfred Newman, a composer who was a pillar of the famous Hollywood sound, who Gerhardt admired and had met: “Newman was a charming man, full of good humor. He was friendly, fun and always had a joke. With his eternal black cigar in hand, he was a composer by trade, down-to-earth, discussed little about himself but was a first-rate advisor in my life. “ Gerhardt would consult certain composers in advance about how to recreate suites from their works, or when this wasn't possible, he would rearrange the suites himself and submit them to the composers for approval. "Some critics complained that my suites were too short, but my aim in the case of each album was to present a well-split 'portrait' of the composer, highlighting his many creative facets". Although Korngold, Newman and Steiner were no longer around to lend their support, Gerhardt was lucky enough to still work with Herrmann, Rózsa and Tiomkin as consultants who turned up at the recording studio to lend a hand. Gerhardt also had the idea of creating albums focusing on a single film star. Three specific volumes were devoted to music from the films of Humphrey Bogart, Errol Flynn and Bette Davis. Although these albums suffer from too great a diversity of genres, they still offer the chance to hear and discover rare and previously unpublished compositions. The best conceived album was arguably the one devoted to Bette Davis. Conscious of the important role played by music in her films, the legendary actress took part in the conception of the album, knowing that it favored scores by Max Steiner designed for Warner Bros. The Collection Begins ! Gerhardt's passion for certain composers knows no bounds, but he soon envisages a disc devoted to Miklos Rozsa, including suites for “Spellbound” and “The Red House”, one of his favorite scores, which he will exhume to create one of the longest suites in the series. At the same time, he received various fan wish lists and films to watch, such as “The Four Feathers”, which he had never seen and which gave him the opportunity to discover a splendid score by Miklos Rozsa that he had never heard before. He was disappointed, however, not to be able to conceive a longer “Spellbound” sequel for rights reasons. Despite RCA's full approval, Gerhardt realized that it was not easy to record film music in its original form, as few were ever edited, played and made available for rental. For The Sea Hawks album, things were simpler, as Georges Korngold had copies of his father's scores, and Warner Bros had also archived material in good condition. From the outset, Gerhardt encountered other major problems in the search for and discovery of scores hidden away in other studios, often with the unpleasant surprise of discovering missing or incomplete conductors, or others heavily modified by orchestrators during recording sessions, or the surprise of discovering, in certain cases, instrumentation information noted in shorthand on the edges of the conductor score. For the disc dedicated to Max Steiner, for example, the conductor score for “King Kong” had disappeared from the RKO archives, having been shipped in 1950 to poorly maintained warehouses in Los Angeles where it had become totally degraded and illegible. With the help of Georges Korngold, Gerhardt was able to reconstruct a substantial suite from the piano models left by Steiner at the time. This experience was repeated when the conductor score for Dimitri Tiomkin's “The Thing” was discovered in the same warehouse, in an advanced state of disintegration. Fortunately for Gerhardt, Tiomkin, who was still alive, had been able to provide precise piano maquettes with orchestration information in shorthand, revealing a complex and highly innovative style of writing. Tiomkin always composed at the piano, inscribing very specific information and signs on the edges of the scores in pencil, an ingenious system of his own invention that was difficult to decipher. “Revisiting the score of ‘The Thing from Another World’ was a complex task, involving experimental passages and an unorthodox orchestra. You can understand that I had a huge job on my hands. When I approached the recording sessions, it was not without some trepidation. However, the composer present made no criticism or comment on my work, and was delighted. He was delighted.” For “Gone With The Wind”, Steiner was against the idea of remaking a complete soundtrack, as he felt that too many passages were repeated. It was an opportunity for him to revisit his own score, integrating his favorite melodies. This synthesis gave him the opportunity to revitalize his music by eliminating the least interesting parts of the score. Conceived as long suites or isolated themes, the discs reflect the essence of the composers' work. The “Classic Film Scores” series by Franz Waxman, Bernard Herrmann and Miklos Rozsa etc will become a big hit with collectors. For Gerhardt, this will be an opportunity to unearth forgotten or rare scores such as Herrmann's “The White Witch” and “On a Dangerous Ground”, Hugo Friedhofer's “The Sun Also Rises” and early recordings for Waxman's “Prince Valliant” and Rozsa's “The Red House”, all with new, impeccable acoustics. For “Elisabeth and Essex”, Erich Korngold had already prepared a suite in the form of an Overture, which was given its world premiere in a theater. The suite for “The Adventures of Robin Hood” also pre-existed. Franz Waxman created his own suite for “A Place in the Sun”, which was also performed in concert. Dimitri Tiomkin, Miklos Rozsa and Bernard Herrmann acted as consultants and contributed arrangements to their scores. For the continuation of “White Witch Doctor”, Bernard Herrman added percussion to link the different musical tableaux. He did the same for the different parts of “Citizen Kane”. Miklos Rozsa saw an opportunity to add a male choir to the suite from “The Jungle Book”, based on an idea by Charles Gerhardt. For the record dedicated to Errol Flynn, Gerhardt re-orchestrated the theme “The Lights of Paris” from Hugo Friedhofer's “The Sun also Rises”, as the original was no longer available. “I wanted to go back to that time and systematically explore the very substance of the great film scores of the late 30s and 40s, sending them back directly to their images as dramatic entities. The desire to rediscover tunes we know and to take into account the contexts in which they were originally used. I decided to recreate these scores with their original orchestrations, and this could only be done by returning to the ultimate sources, as the composers had originally conceived them.” Keen to open up the collection to other genres, such as science fiction, Gerhardt dedicated two further albums to the series in 1992. The first featured contemporary sequels to “Star Wars” and “Close Encounters of the Third Kind”, promoting the work of John Williams, a leading composer of new film music. Then another called “The Spectacular World of Classic Film Scores”, presenting a disappointing compilation of scores that had already been recorded, except for the creation of a sequel to Dimitri Tiomkin's “The Thing From Another World” and Daniele Amfitheatrof's rarely heard theme “Dance of the Seven Voiles” from Salome. In 1978, the collection was published in Spain by RCA Cinema Treasures. In the USA and Europe, the Classic Film Scores LP series was reissued in the early 80s with a black art deco cover and colored star index. All Volumes in the First Series Were Reissued : By the end of the '80s, the series was running out of steam, and Charles Gerhardt planned to relaunch his collection with albums dedicated to famous American actresses, a new volume for Max Steiner and the Western, a volume reconstructing the score of Waxman's “The Bride of Frankenstein”, followed by volumes devoted to Alex North, Hugo Friedhofer, Victor Young and Elmer Bernstein... But RCA would not support Gerhardt in these projects, preferring to release the collection on CD for the first time. In early 1990, RCA asked Gerhardt to supervise and co-produce the collection, which he saw as an opportunity to revisit some of the volumes, inserting tracks that had not appeared on the LPs or extending certain suites. The volume devoted to Franz Waxman, “Sunset Boulevard”, was the first to be released. The CD did not benefit from any particular promotion, but sold very well, as did the other CDs that followed... A collection marked by a new design in silver pantone. The CDs series was reissued in 2010, still under the RCA Red Seal label, but distributed by Sony Music Entertainment. RCA Victor's Classic Films Scores series represents a unique collection in the history of film music recordings. 14 recordings of rare quality, produced by Georges Korngold and Charles Gerhardt to become one of the revelations of the reissue phenomenon. Other Concepts... Later, Gerhardt spent most of his time in London, continuing to make recordings. After retiring from RCA in 1986, he returned to independent work for Readers Digest and other record labels, a position he held in production and musical supervision until 1997. Since 1991 he had lived in Redding, California. In later years, he did not appear professionally, refusing all public invitations because of his desire to remain discreet. In his entourage he was close to three cousins, Lenore L Engel and Elizabeth Anne Schuetze, both living in San Antonio, and cousin Steven W Gerhardt of St. Pete Beach, Florida. In late November 1998 Charles Gerhardt was diagnosed with brain cancer and died of complications following surgery on February 22, 1999. He was 72 years old. Thus ends this tribute to Charles Gerhardt and the most famous collection of film music records: The Classic Film Scores series.
by Doug Raynes 24 Jan, 2024
Following on from Tadlow’s epic recording of El Cid, the same team – Nic Raine conducting and James Fitzpatrick producing – have turned their attention to a completely different type of epic film for the definitive recording of Ernest Gold’s Academy Award winning score for Otto Preminger’s Exodus (1960). The score is something of a revelation because aside from the main theme, the music has received little attention through recordings. Additionally the sound quality of the original soundtrack LP was disappointing and much music was deleted or cut from the film.
Share by: